Who do we give in to?

Screengrab: women's Liberation 50th Anniversary Celebration conference Live Stream

That’s the kind of question 21st century feminists should be asking, is it?

What happened? Some women in Oxford set about organising a 50-years-on commemorative Women’s Liberation event. Trouble is, there’s a bit of a split in feminism going on. (Go search ‘third wave’ and ‘fourth wave’ to find out more).

Tweet from Selina Todd: Just to note the event I've been no platformed at is not organised by Ruskin College, but by @OxIntWomensFest at @ExeterCollegeOx. (Artwork courtesy of @janeclarejones). Since the autumn I've helped the organisers to get media coverage and support from @OxfordHistory.The speakers they’d lined up included Selina Todd, who has recently given a talk at Women’s Place UK. Apparently, two other speakers said they wouldn’t speak if she did.


A comment heard from one of the organisers was “who should we give in to?” Well, let us try to answer that:

The options there would be to no-platform Todd, or to tell the other speakers that conferences tend to include more than one opinion and that they should be ready to be disagreed with.

Women's Liberation at 50 header, augmented by notes from Jane Clare Jones, under the title "Male Dominence"It seems pretty obvious to me that option one is repressive, whereas option two leaves all three women the opportunity to have their say – therefore a force for liberation should go for option two.


But, according to a comment by one of the organisers, they had been threatened with disruption if they allowed Todd to speak. They are clearly very averse to disruption, as they asked Todd to no-platform herself, so they didn’t get the flack for so doing.

The nature of liberation


List of speakers with Selina Todd tippexed out

Can you get liberation without disruption? The much-lauded suffragettes certainly didn’t. Did any of the gains for women’s rights happen without disruption? Don’t think so. Are the Oxford women now having a nice, peaceful disruption-free conference?

I do hope not because if they are, I suggest that no kind of liberation is going on.

Screen grab from FiLiA.org who published "the talk that should have been by Selina Todd

Click here to read the ten minute talk Selina Todd didn’t get a chance to present.


The question most admirably answered…

screenshot of a comment: 'As with everything in life, you turn down the people who force you to make a choice.


Meanwhile Dr Jane Clare Jones was at full steam over on Twitter.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: